Petal Mary Jane Knit Flat

I bought these as a last-minute dupe for a popular *washable* brand that costs about 3x as much as these. These are not washable, but surprisingly, out of the box, they were insanely comfortable. I bought them to wear to an event, and had not broken them in yet. Minutes before I left I found out I could not get an Uber and would have to walk over a mile to the venue. I did place heel pads in the heels (I have narrow heels that often slip/rub) and bandaids over my instep in an area that I suspected would rub… I had no issues with the walk to the venue and wore these without issue for the next 6 hours. The only problem I can see is what others have mentioned… the strap is not engineered to last, and it is already fraying/fuzzing. I usually like to buy a more quality shoe, but these worked in a pinch for a trendy look, and will likely last a season or maybe two. I also purchased my normal size (9, with a wide-ish ball and narrow heel), and they fit perfectly.

I got these for my mom who always complains about her shoes. These fit her perfectly and the sizing was accurate. She loves the material and how easy it is to wear and take off. It is extremely comfortable and she feels like she isn't even wearing the shoe. Her feet do slip on and off without having to open the buckle every time so that's also great and it looks presentable.

These are cute shoes and I have likes and dislikes about them. I like the knit material of the shoes. The Mary Jane straps are a nice touch that dress them up a bit and allow you to wear them casually as well as with dressier options. The buckle on the strap is pretty, easy to buckle and good quality. They are fairly comfortable. There’s not a lot of support or padding, but enough that they aren’t uncomfortable. I like the way they look and find them as a nice shoe to pair with many different outfits. The fit is okay, but could be better. Length wise, they fit as expected, but I did feel like they were a little on the wide side. There is a little gap between my feet and the sides of the shoes that feel a little off to me. I also don’t think the quality matches the price point. They are not bad quality, just not $40 quality. My biggest quality concern is the straps on the shoes. They are the knit material with a little piece of leather type fabric where the holes are. The knit part of the straps are already showing signs of some fraying which make me concerned that they may not last as long as I would expect. Overall, they are cute shoes with some good features and some that could be improved.

I wear a size 9 so I ordered a nine, and they fit great! They are super comfortable, the strap is nice and elastic for my high arches, and the arch support inside the shoe is okay, but I ALWAYS use arch supports in my shoes, so that probably wouldn't be an issue for most folks. They are knit, so they are fair-weather shoes, for sure. I can't wait to wear them with my summer outfits!

I love these black Mary Jane shoes. You can wear them with or without socks. They are amazingly comfortable! I’ve had them on all day! They look great with anything! Dresses, jeans, skirts, etc. I’m Extremely pleased with them. They are very well-made. I highly recommend them.

These are perfect for walking long periods when I’m working but want to be stylish. They have cushions inside the shoe to keep the comfort. I love how it helps with the arch have in my foot. Super cute I definitely want more in different colors.

For starters, they look just like they do in the stock photo. I ordered my normal size, and they fit right. They are quite lightweight and are comfortable to wear. You can adjust the buckle as needed. The beige color will go well with many things. I wouldn't wear these except in nice weather. For what they are, they are good, but I think that the asking price is too high.

I have a few pair in this brand. Love them and they are so comfy

I decided I needed some shoes in a neutral color and I am so happy with this choice! The shoes have memory foam inside so they are very, very comfortable. In person the color has a slightly more blush tint to them but still very neutral color so they are good to go with lots of clothing colors. I like Mary Jane look and the strap helps to keep my feet from accidentally slipping out of the shoe. The tow box is plenty wide enough too. I ordered an 8 and they are maybe the *tiniest* bit big but I also like my shoes to be roomy so they are perfect for me. These are already in my regular shoe rotation!

These shoes are very comfortable! They fit a wide foot just fine. There isn't a lot of arch support but they are pretty well padded on the inside. Would recommend.

love the shoe but it's not wide enough. the color is wonderful but since it's so tight I won't be able to walk very far.

Loved at first but the back of the heel gave me blisters. I hope they work on a new design soon. The shoe is giving Rothy’s and i love the simplicity but this shoe’s performance isnt a 5/5, it felt cheaply made.

I was super excited about these flats. I bought them for my conference in italy. However 10 minutes into wearing them I had blisters on the back of my heels. I would like to return them but because of the roughness of the back of the shoe there is blood on them. I might just have to put something there to prevent them from developing again. Im disappointed

Great shoes for work and great for wearing without socks

Nice product for the price. Very comfortable.

Surprising comfortable and also surprisingly don’t make your feet sweaty or stinky. 5/5!!

Cute adorable shoes. Took a minute to get comfortable but I wear sock inserts and they feel really great!

They took some time to wear in, but they are cute! I have very narrow feet and there seemed a little wide for me but they are roomy if you need it!

Comfortable and also very stylish

Awesome shoes , very comfortable

Love these shoes! So comfy but they look fancy, with a dress or jeans, I got beige too. Considering the navy ones as well. I was wearing them on vacation where we took an impromptu hike and they held up on wet rocks! Not slippery at all. Love them and they’re easy to clean.

Wide is wide. I would probably get a regular width but for the price it’s great!

These are adorable in person but unfortunately I’m a size 5.5/6 and the 6 was huge on me. I’d suggest sizing down at least a half size. Definitely don’t size up!! I would order if they came in smaller sizes.

I thought these shoes are cute and comfort. Plenty of room in the two area. Nice casual vibe. I would not recommend walking all day in them. They are good for my desk job. A little expensive for the quality but overall I'm happy with them.